Islamorada Fish Company

81532 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, Florida Keys, Florida

3.5

User Rating (2 sources) ×

Phone:

305-664-9271,800-258-2559

Website:

www.islamoradafishcompany.com

For two star dining in Islamorada, try Islamorada Fish Company. It's known for its seafood. This place features great views. Upon entering the restaurant, you'll ... more on Open List

Read Reviews

View Map & Directions

Ratings & Reviews for Islamorada Fish Company from Around the Web

Avg Rating

15 reviews

100% of guests recommend this place.

Atmosphere:

Dining:

Service & Staff:

Value:

Top Reviews from Around the Web:

Food was good drinks not all that. more on Yahoo! Travel

The seafood is as fresh as it gets. more on Yahoo! Travel

Overall would have been 5 stars if we didnt have such a bad waitress. more on Yahoo! Travel

My first time there 02/09 the food was much better. more on Yahoo! Travel

But the food is worth the wait. more on Yahoo! Travel

Avg Rating

5 reviews

Top Reviews From Yahoo! Travel

Right from the start, the hostess was a pleasure. She made us feel at home and directed us to the bar while we waited for a table - 10 mins. Just enough time for a frozen margarita. Service was quick and friendly. Food came out ... more on Yahoo! Travel

It's a really nice to go sit out on the dock and have lunch. Very tropical feel. The seafood is as fresh as it gets. The service is good to very good. But on holiday weekends, there may be a crowd. But the food is worth the wait. ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Overall would have been 5 stars if we didnt have such a bad waitress. It wasnt even that busy when we were there and we had really bad service. She gave us the check without even asking ... more on Yahoo! Travel

The IFC original location has become a required stop on the way to Key West. Over the years, management has perfected the craft of selling simple, straightforward fish meals without much fuss or too many mishaps. In other words, simple, ... more on Yahoo! Travel

We really enjoyed the Fish Company. The food was wonderful and the view was even better. After dinner, we walked along the docks and saw two large manatees and a baby manatee right beside the dock. Some children were even petting ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Avg Rating

10 reviews

Top Reviews From TripAdvisor

We really enjoyed this spot, We made it in time for the sunset, Wow what a view. I had stone crab that was 2 hours/fresh My Girl Friend had Lobster that was very tender ... more on TripAdvisor

The outside location is nice for dining and the food is pretty good but a little high for what they give you. I like the Key West shrimp pasta. It's on the water and you can boat right up to their doc ... more on TripAdvisor

The location is ideal and the outdoor dining area with its view of the bayside water is lovely. That said, the service was painfully slow and unorganized (my meal arrive 10 minutes after my family's). ... more on TripAdvisor

I use trip advisor all of the time. Even in France. I got a password in order to write this review. I eat out at least 2 meals a day. I took a few days off to go down to the Keys. I think some of the ... more on TripAdvisor

Food is becoming more franchisy...but still a pretty good eat. more on TripAdvisor

See Reviews From:

Top Reviews From Yahoo! Travel

This place had a nice key largo feel. next to the bayside. Food was good drinks not all that. Good & Fast service more on Yahoo! Travel

I must say I was quite disappointed in the food. My first time there 02/09 the food was much better. I believe I had the fried shrimps. I was there again 3/10 I had the broiled grouper(no flavor). ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Enjoying the freshest seafood with a cool tropical drink entertained by the local tarpon sitting ... more on Yahoo! Travel