»

Carmelina's @ The Commons

96 Russell St, Hadley, Massachusetts

3.0

User Rating (1 sources) ×

TripAdvisor

Phone:

+1 413 584 8000

Website:

carmelinas.com

Read Reviews

View Map & Directions

Ratings & Reviews for Carmelina's @ The Commons from Around the Web

Avg Rating

10 reviews

100% of guests recommend this place.

Atmosphere:

Dining:

Service & Staff:

Value:

Top Reviews from Around the Web:

Although the service was slow at times both my partner and I were looking for a quiet and leisurely evening and this fit the bill. more on Yahoo! Travel

Things happen when you are dealing with the public but our experience proved to be less satisfactory than the disgruntled customers who left. more on Yahoo! Travel

We may have to become regulars..: What a stellar dining experience. more on Yahoo! Travel

To bad the service was so poor.: Upon arrival it was evident the restaurant is poorly managed. more on Yahoo! Travel

We won't go back more on Yahoo! Travel

Avg Rating

10 reviews

Top Reviews From TripAdvisor

Let me begin by saying our experience at Carmelina's was enjoyable. We visited Carmelina's midweek in November. We were greeted politely, and shown to a table for two along a wall with a common bench ... more on TripAdvisor

My husband and I live the area...hadn't been to Carmelina's for several years and decided to check it out. since it's had great local ratings over the past few years under new management. The first th ... more on TripAdvisor

It was Famly Weekend at Smith College, and this restaurant was willing to accept a reservation for three, when others would not. ... more on TripAdvisor

While the food was okay, the atmosphere was noisy. Piano music is nice but makes it difficult to carry on a conversation. I have ordered a ... more on TripAdvisor

I was exhausted and starving when I arrived at Carmelina's. My red Zinfandel wine was very good, salad fresh and the puttanesca--which came in 5 levels of heat--was very tasty. It was nice to see that ... more on TripAdvisor

Top Reviews From Yahoo! Travel

We may have to become regulars..: What a stellar dining experience. We were greeted quickly and were given a pleasant table for two. Our waitor was superb friendly experienced and ready to suggest options if we asked. Although the ... more on Yahoo! Travel

To bad the service was so poor.: Upon arrival it was evident the restaurant is poorly managed. Customers were disgruntled with the service and wait staff atitude. Things happen when you are dealing with the public but our experience ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Poor servicestaff with attitude. Mediocre all around. We won't go back more on Yahoo! Travel