»

Peter Pan Diner

Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, New York

3.5

User Rating (3 sources) ×

TripAdvisor
CitySearch
Restaurantica

View More Photos

Phone:

+1 631 665 1788

Website:

peterpandiner.org

Peter Pan Diner located just off Sunrise Hwy in Bay Shore Long Island. more on Peterpandiner.org

Read Reviews

View Map & Directions

Ratings & Reviews for Peter Pan Diner from Around the Web

Avg Rating

9 reviews

Atmosphere:

Dining:

Service & Staff:

Value:

Top Reviews from Around the Web:

The food arrived very quickly & was fresh, the service was what you would expect from a diner (pretty good) But not black tie lol. more on TripAdvisor

Breakfast food or dinner food it's all great served hot. more on Yahoo! Travel

Love a good burger! more on Restaurantica

Excellent service and menu. more on Restaurantica

Awesome food-I understand they have a real chef that makes some of the specials-We have tried the pot pie (excellent) the pasta bolognese sauce (so fresh & good) penne ala vodka (great) 4 cheese mac and cheese (to die for) and the chicken fancaise (sauce is perfecto). more on Yahoo! Travel

Avg Rating

4 reviews

Top Reviews From TripAdvisor

went to lunch and had fresh turkey sandwich, fries and unsweetened tea. I wanted dessert but there was no room for it. I took half the sandwich home, it was so big, and left the fries, because they we ... more on TripAdvisor

I've lived on Long Island my entire life and always went to either the Oconee or Sea Crest Diners because my grandfather did work for the owners. When I turned 16, I got my first job, as a waiter, at ... more on TripAdvisor

Stopped here for the first time on the way to the beach one weekday morning. After looking at the breakfast menu, I ordered an omelet and my friend ordered pancakes. She asked if it came with anything ... more on TripAdvisor

After an unpleasant experiance at another local diner I decided to check out this one I have often past by (but never went in before) And I have to say that despite the outward apperance, the peter pa ... more on TripAdvisor

See Reviews From:

Top Reviews From Yahoo! Travel

We have being going once a week to Peter Pan for the new Stimulas Menu. Awesome food - I understand they have a real chef that makes some of the specials - We have tried the pot pie ( excellent) the pasta bolognese sauce (so fresh ... more on Yahoo! Travel

I rather go hungry than eat at this diner. My friend ordered a wrap and found dead ants. Need I say more! more on Yahoo! Travel

GREAT PLACE TO RELAX & EAT: With so many diners on LI Peter Pan is one of the best!! For the price you get tons of food. Dinners come with bread salad or soup and several veggies choices. Whenever I'm exhausted or just want to treat ... more on Yahoo! Travel