Old Homestead Restaurant

  • 472 Bridgeville Rd, Monticello, NY 12701
3.0
User Rating (1 sources) ×
  • Best of Uptake
    Best of Uptake 2011

    Winners were selected based on over 20 million opinions from over 5,000 local, travel and lifestyle sources.

    Is this your business?
Congratulations!
You have one of the Best of Uptake awards.

If you would like to include this award badge on your website, copy and paste the code below.

Size: 154 x 38

Phone:

+1 845 794 8973

Old Homestead Restaurant is located in New York. It's known for its steak. more on Open List

Read Reviews

View Map & Directions

1 sources × 10 reviews
3.0
User Rating

Our Take

Ratings & Reviews for Old Homestead Restaurant from Around the Web

Avg Rating

10 reviews

  • Atmosphere:

  • Dining:

  • Service & Staff:

  • Value:

Top Reviews from Around the Web:

Very good food, tender meet, a little on expensive side. more on TripAdvisor

We love the food and the bread is terrific!!!! more on CitySearch

Went to this restaurant on a strong recommendation and was very disappointed. more on Yahoo! Travel

Food is always predictable and good service. more on CitySearch

Wouldn't haven't been so bad but we paid over $120 (excl tip) for 2 appetizers 2 entrees and 2 glasses of reasonable wine. more on Yahoo! Travel

Avg Rating

10 reviews

Top Reviews From TripAdvisor

We visited during our stay at Lake Joseph. The homemade bread was fantastic. The water was the best I have tasted in a long time, so much so that I had to ask if it was tap water. To my surprise it wa ... more on TripAdvisor

Great steaks.......The best resturant in the area....!! more on TripAdvisor

I have a friend that grew up in the area and had been raving about it for years. Aside from the bread, there is nothing special about this restuarant. The steaks were burnt and fatty and were ... more on TripAdvisor

This restaurant has been a staple in the Monticello area for at least 50 years. The food is very good. The service is superb, although ... more on TripAdvisor

From the moment you walked in you felt like family..very nice and great food...top dining for this area. more on TripAdvisor

See Reviews From:

  1. Yahoo! Travel

  2. CitySearch

Top Reviews From Yahoo! Travel

Went to this restaurant on a strong recommendation and was very disappointed. Food was not fresh (both myself and my girlfriend ordered fish dishes and both were not fresh our side of brocolli had clearly been cooked from frozen) ... more on Yahoo! Travel

We went to The Old Homestead to celebrate our fifth wedding anniversary on a recent Saturday night. Although the restaurant was relatively empty when we got there around 6:30 p.m. we waited about 10 minutes before we were greeted ... more on Yahoo! Travel

GREATEST STEAK HOUSE EVER!!!: I loved everthing in this place. My wife and I went here and the people were great they all were very friendly. The service was great and soo was the food. They have the best bread that you will ever ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Location & Nearby Attractions

Monticello Lodging

Monticello Things To Do

Monticello Nightlife

New York Resources

© 2006 - 2012 Uptake Networks, Inc.

Uptake

Get the best tips and advice by discovering which of your friends have been to Monticello, and also reach our helpful and experienced Uptake travel community. Sign in!

×
Uptake

Did you know that your Internet Explorer is out of date?


To get the best possible experience using our website we recommend that you upgrade to a newer version.

Close