Carmine's

200 W 44th St, New York City, New York

4.5

User Rating (4 sources) ×

TripAdvisor
Yahoo! Travel
CitySearch
Restaurantica

Congratulations!

You have one of the Best of Uptake awards.

If you would like to include this award badge on your website, copy and paste the code below.

Size: 154 x 38

Yahoo! Travel

Phone:

+1 212 221 3800

Website:

www.carminesnyc.com

Email:

Info_theater@carminesnyc.com

A Theatre District favorite, Carmine's features large servings of good Southern ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Read Reviews

View Map & Directions

4 sources ×

TripAdvisor
Yahoo! Travel
Restaurantica
CitySearch

212 reviews

4.5

User Rating

Our Take

Ratings & Reviews for Carmine's from Around the Web

Avg Rating

212 reviews

98% of guests recommend this place.

Atmosphere:

Dining:

Service & Staff:

Value:

Top Reviews from Around the Web:

Carmine's has wonderful food...the portions are huge and for a great price. more on Yahoo! Travel

The manager rudely informed us that it is just pasta and we should not be upset. more on CitySearch

The portions are generous and the food is good quality classic Italian food. more on Restaurantica

i have been several times to midtown location and always had a great meal,always shared and service is both pleasant and attentive also quite resonable more on GoCityKids

The atmosphere is festive, like one big fat Italian wedding. more on We8There

Avg Rating

112 reviews

Top Reviews From Yahoo! Travel

A%E's Growing Up Gotti pushed Victoria's oldest son, Carmine to open up this restaurant, and yes, the name brought me here, but the FOOD ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Every time I visit New York I eat at Carmine's just before a broadway show. It is located in the heart of the theater district. If you love authentic, homestyle Italian food, then Carmine's is the place. It bustling, noisy, and exciting. ... more on Yahoo! Travel

This place has a good rep for food and now I know why-- We had a terrific meal and can't wait to come back! more on Yahoo! Travel

They say family style they mean family style. If your hungry it's a good place to eat but, remember to bring a group of people because their portions are very big. It's very tasty and the service was good. We did have to wait a while ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Wonderful food. Be prepared to share portions. Plenty of food in entrees for two. Don't be tempted to fill up on the varied ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Avg Rating

10 reviews

Top Reviews From TripAdvisor

Very good option for dining family style before or after a broadway show. The meals are delicious but not ... more on TripAdvisor

Never go alone to this restaurant!. Huge dishes to share with two or three friends. Quality and service was correct, but ... more on TripAdvisor

A large bowl of food, to feed almost 5 people, for a good price, but the food has taste of nothing at all. The menu is confusing to understand, specially if you ... more on TripAdvisor

I was impressed by how good the food here was. Every choice was delicious. Can get crowded. more on TripAdvisor

Try it... You'll like it! Make a reservation. Don't try and walk in more on TripAdvisor

Avg Rating

3 reviews

See Reviews From:

Top Reviews From Restaurantica

Good food, nice size protions if you share. Go during off hours, wait is too long. more on Restaurantica

Awesome, tender juicy, huge steaks. The best at a reasonable cost. more on Restaurantica

My husband and I like eating heer before seeing a broadway show. The portions are generous and the food is good quality classic Italian food. ... more on Restaurantica