One if by Land, Two if by Sea

17 Barrow St, New York City, New York

4.5

User Rating (4 sources) ×

Restaurantica
Yahoo! Travel
TripAdvisor
CitySearch

Congratulations!

You have one of the Best of Uptake awards.

If you would like to include this award badge on your website, copy and paste the code below.

Size: 154 x 38

TripAdvisor

View More Photos

Phone:

+1 212 255 8649

Website:

www.oneifbyland.com

Email:

info@oneifbyland.com

This restaurant is utterly romantic it-features piano music, flowers, fireplaces, balcony seating and dim lighting. ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Read Reviews

View Map & Directions

4 sources ×

Yahoo! Travel
TripAdvisor
Restaurantica
CitySearch

275 reviews

4.5

User Rating

Our Take

Ratings & Reviews for One if by Land, Two if by Sea from Around the Web

Avg Rating

275 reviews

91% of guests recommend this place.

Atmosphere:

Dining:

Service & Staff:

Value:

Top Reviews from Around the Web:

During our honeymoon in NYC, we enjoyed a special evening in this beautiful setting. more on Yahoo! Travel

-we were seated promptly, the service was excellent and the food was AMAZING! more on CitySearch

My 15 year old daughter adores the restaurant and, on a recent visit to the city, we went back there for dinner. more on Restaurantica

The highlight of my meal was the creme brulee more on We8There

The food here is good-The service is good but the seating / tables are only 6 inches apart-So much for personal conversation. more on Yahoo! Travel

Avg Rating

68 reviews

Top Reviews From Yahoo! Travel

This place is perfect for an occasion due to the prices it is the only way I could rationalize giving OIBL a great review. The food and service will rival any great establishment in the City and the Ambiance is perfect ... more on Yahoo! Travel

I like it totally yahoo of the somany things but iam not go any where some badi say iam fill up the form but yahoo is the best ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Loved it!!!!! more on Yahoo! Travel

Best place more on Yahoo! Travel

Such a romantic, passionate place to go to dine. more on Yahoo! Travel

Avg Rating

10 reviews

Top Reviews From TripAdvisor

We eloped in NYC over the holidays and chose One if by Land, Two if by Sea for our celebration dinner. It was just the two of us. Our only disappointment lay with the seating. When I reserved the tabl ... more on TripAdvisor

Have been there several time but on this occassion they had done a reno of the dining room. the large cut glass partition anlong with the more modern banquet seating was very nice. Service was attenti ... more on TripAdvisor

Really good food but formal and a little stuffy. more on TripAdvisor

A nice place to have a romantic dinner. This place is very popular around Valentine's Day. more on TripAdvisor

Enjoyed the food and location. Great history. Good service, food and atmosphere. Really enjoy this restaurant. more on TripAdvisor

See Reviews From:

Top Reviews From igougo

This restaurant is a true gem! Set in an eighteenth-century carriage house once owned by Aaron Burr, the bi-level dining room is ... more on igougo

This restaurant is such a nice and intimate experience. We were seated by a warm fireplace, and the food was just excellent. I think ... more on igougo

Wow. What can I say about this place- they aren't kidding when they call it the most romantic restaurant in NYC. Firelit space in ... more on igougo

The best part about this dining experience was the atmosphere and ambience. The restaurant is in a quaint brownstone like building ... more on igougo