New Paradise Cafe

  • 126 Main Street, Sag Harbor, Long Island, New York
3.0
User Rating (1 sources) ×

Phone:

+1 631 725 6080

Inventive and fresh seasonal dishes ... more on Gayot

Read Reviews

View Map & Directions

Ratings & Reviews for New Paradise Cafe from Around the Web

Avg Rating

10 reviews

100% of guests recommend this place.

  • Atmosphere:

  • Dining:

  • Service & Staff:

  • Value:

Top Reviews from Around the Web:

The management supports the town in many ways, and it puts out consistently great quality food and drink that has never disappointed. more on TripAdvisor

We have always had an excellent experience with the food and the staff at the New Paradise! more on TripAdvisor

Risotto so over-cooked it was mush-and maybe a drop of truffle oil and cheap mushrooms. more on TripAdvisor

Fine food and wonderful staff make it even more enjoyable. more on TripAdvisor

Avg Rating

10 reviews

Top Reviews From TripAdvisor

One of my worst dining experiences in the Hamptons was at The New Paradise. I ordered salmon which was supposed to be medium rare but it was well done. That was only minor though. My husband who is a ... more on TripAdvisor

This is not a romantic out of the way bistro, but more a local place that good friends can meet for wonderful food and equally good service. Whether you're looking for a light bite before the movie or ... more on TripAdvisor

A nice interesting diverse menu. Something interesting for everyone. If you are in town for a few days make this a stop more on TripAdvisor

Being greated by the ever fabulous Eric Peele at the door started our evening off wonderfully! Eric was a delight who helped us with a wine selection and then recommended some hors and entrees. Everyt ... more on TripAdvisor

We're locals and this is, hands down, our favorite restaurant. Eric and team offer delicious food with remarkable consistency and wonderful service. We've never had a bad meal here and we've been goin ... more on TripAdvisor

Great Amenities at New Paradise Cafe:

  • Bar dining
  • Beer
  • Personal wines welcome (corkage fee applies)
  • Cafe
  • Full bar
  • Non-smoking restaurant
  • Takeout
  • Patio/outdoor dining

Location & Nearby Attractions

Sag Harbor Lodging

Sag Harbor Things To Do

Sag Harbor Nightlife

New York Resources

© 2006 - 2012 Uptake Networks, Inc.

Uptake

Get the best tips and advice by discovering which of your friends have been to Sag Harbor, and also reach our helpful and experienced Uptake travel community. Sign in!

×
Uptake

Did you know that your Internet Explorer is out of date?


To get the best possible experience using our website we recommend that you upgrade to a newer version.

Close