»

Sweet Tomato's

15 Grand Ave, Shelter Island, Long Island, New York

3.0

User Rating (1 sources) ×

TripAdvisor

Phone:

+1 631 749 4114

Sweet Tomato's Restaurant And Bar is located in New York. Locals say the restaurant serves genuine Italian dishes. Know before you go: this place features live music. When you ... more on Open List

Read Reviews

View Map & Directions

Ratings & Reviews for Sweet Tomato's from Around the Web

Avg Rating

10 reviews

100% of guests recommend this place.

Atmosphere:

Dining:

Service & Staff:

Value:

Top Reviews from Around the Web:

This newish venture in the tiny town of Shelter Island Heights is quickly catching on as a good dinner stop after antiquing. more on Frommers

Avg Rating

10 reviews

Top Reviews From TripAdvisor

We ate at the bar and thoroughly enjoyed our dinner. The local scallops were delicious, as was the fresh pasta. Interesting selection ... more on TripAdvisor

Rude hostess started off disappointing evening. Much better choices on Shelter Island. more on TripAdvisor

Visiting Shelter Island in the middle of the week during the off-season, we didn't have much of a selection of eating establishments. But we're glad that Sweet Tomato's was one of only a few options, ... more on TripAdvisor

We went to Sweet Tomato's for lunch and overall it was by far the best meal we had during our stay on Shelter Island. They have a small balcony overlooking the street at the front which unfortunately ... more on TripAdvisor

We really enjoyed this spot. Great fresh fish prepared in an interesting way, fresh produce. Waitstaff was pleasant, helpful. more on TripAdvisor

Top Reviews From Frommers

This newish venture in the tiny town of Shelter Island Heights is quickly catching on as a good dinner stop after antiquing. The menu doesn't ... more on Frommers