Shelter Island Restaurants - Shelter Island NY Dining Guide

21 activities found from 5,000 sites

AVine Street Cafe

Average Rating
4.0
5+ reviews
from 3 sources
Restaurantica
0.0
1+ reviews
Yelp
5.0
3+ reviews
CitySearch
4.5
1+ reviews
  • Fresh, delicious, Vine Street Cafe's cuisine is deserved of a devoted following. And it has. They serve local seafood always ... more on citysearch.com
  • Loved it. Despite our Ford truck being the most downscale auto in the lot (convertible ... more on yelp.com
Vine Street Cafe
41 S Ferry Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964

BDory

Average Rating
3.0
6+ reviews
from 2 sources
Yelp
2.5
5+ reviews
CitySearch
3.5
1+ reviews
  • Restaurant / Bar on Shelter ... more on yelp.com
  • ATTN: The Dory is not really a dive bar despite it's outer divey appearance. ... more on yelp.com
Dory
185 N Ferry Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11965

CPlanet Bliss Incorporated

Average Rating
4.0
2+ reviews
from 2 sources
CitySearch
3.5
1+ reviews
Yelp
4.0
1+ reviews
  • Manna. I would eat here all the time if I lived on the island. Unfortunately they ... more on yelp.com
  • Overview You can't miss this brightly painted, funky restaurant ... more on Fodor's
Planet Bliss Incorporated
23 N Ferry Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964

DSunset Beach

Average Rating
3.5
2+ reviews
from 1 sources
CitySearch
3.5
2+ reviews
  • The food is great! The staff are totally hip, beautiful and fun. Great music. Stay till the ... more on citysearch.com
  • The service is so rude that can make you forget how beautiful is the restaurant, ... more on citysearch.com
Sunset Beach
37 Shore Rd
Shelter Isle HTS, NY 11965

ECafe 27

Average Rating
3.5
2+ reviews
from 2 sources
Yelp
3.0
1+ reviews
CitySearch
3.5
1+ reviews
  • The food here was excellent and the decor was very classy. Steak was great, though ... more on yelp.com
Cafe 27
27 N Ferry Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964

FMichael Anthony's At Dering

Average Rating
3.5
1+ reviews
from 1 sources
CitySearch
3.5
1+ reviews
Michael Anthony's At Dering
65 S Menantic Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964

GShelter Island Bake Shop

Average Rating
3.5
1+ reviews
from 1 sources
CitySearch
3.5
1+ reviews
Shelter Island Bake Shop
27 N Ferry Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964

HOn Shore

On Shore
13 Winthrop Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964

IDory

Average Rating
3.5
1+ reviews
from 1 sources
CitySearch
3.5
1+ reviews
Dory
114 Bridge St
Shelter Island, NY 11965

JStars

Average Rating
3.5
1+ reviews
from 1 sources
CitySearch
3.5
1+ reviews
Stars
17 Grand Ave
Shelter Isle HTS, NY 11965