Sweet Tomato's

  • 15 Grand Ave, Shelter Island, Long Island, New York
3.0
User Rating (1 sources) ×

Phone:

+1 631 749 4114

This eatery in the tiny town of Shelter Island Heights is quickly catching on as a good dinner stop after antiquing. The menu doesn't present any surprises, but in the bright, cheery restaurant with classic hardwood floors, the ... more on Frommers

Read Reviews

View Map & Directions

Ratings & Reviews for Sweet Tomato's from Around the Web

Avg Rating

10 reviews

100% of guests recommend this place.

  • Atmosphere:

  • Dining:

  • Service & Staff:

  • Value:

Top Reviews from Around the Web:

I appreciate that they stay open in the off season for many of us locals to have a place on the Island to dine. more on Yahoo! Travel

Has to be one of the best restaurants we go to! more on Yahoo! Travel

We go there with 2 other couples and every year all of have had some of the best food ever! more on Yahoo! Travel

The restaurant is always consistent with good food friendly service and fair prices. more on Yahoo! Travel

Avg Rating

10 reviews

Top Reviews From TripAdvisor

We ate at the bar and thoroughly enjoyed our dinner. The local scallops were delicious, as was the fresh pasta. Interesting selection ... more on TripAdvisor

Rude hostess started off disappointing evening. Much better choices on Shelter Island. more on TripAdvisor

Visiting Shelter Island in the middle of the week during the off-season, we didn't have much of a selection of eating establishments. But we're glad that Sweet Tomato's was one of only a few options, ... more on TripAdvisor

We really enjoyed this spot. Great fresh fish prepared in an interesting way, fresh produce. Waitstaff was pleasant, helpful. more on TripAdvisor

This restaurant gets better and better. And the bar is fabulous! more on TripAdvisor

Top Reviews From Yahoo! Travel

we have now been there 3 years in a row when we take our boat to Greenport. We dingy over to Shelter and walk up to ST's. Has to be one of the best restaurants we go to! We go there with 2 other couples and every year all ... more on Yahoo! Travel

The restaurant is always consistent with good food friendly service and fair prices. I appreciate that they stay open in the off season for many of ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Location & Nearby Attractions

Shelter Island Lodging

Shelter Island Things To Do

Shelter Island Nightlife

New York Resources

© 2006 - 2012 Uptake Networks, Inc.

Uptake

Get the best tips and advice by discovering which of your friends have been to Shelter Island, and also reach our helpful and experienced Uptake travel community. Sign in!

×
Uptake

Did you know that your Internet Explorer is out of date?


To get the best possible experience using our website we recommend that you upgrade to a newer version.

Close