21 Main

21 Montauk Highway, West Sayville, New York

3.5

User Rating (3 sources) ×

Congratulations!

You have one of the Best of Uptake awards.

If you would like to include this award badge on your website, copy and paste the code below.

Size: 154 x 38

OpenTable.com

Phone:

+1 631 567 0900

Website:

www.21main.com

Email:

Ryan.Scollan@lovinoven.com

You are sure to have a fun time at this restaurant. Housed in a lovely looking historical mansion, this ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Read Reviews

View Map & Directions

3 sources ×

10 reviews

3.5

User Rating

Our Take

Ratings & Reviews for 21 Main from Around the Web

Avg Rating

10 reviews

Atmosphere:

Dining:

Service & Staff:

Value:

Top Reviews from Around the Web:

Thursday night is a steal at this great steak house....there are special value meals that would cost almost double on Fridays and Saturdays....the steaks are great, the veggies are crisp and fresh and the onion rings yummy....the Ceasar salad is different and delicious You won't be sorry.. 2 regulars on Thursday night more on Yahoo! Travel

Moved out of Sayville to Florida several years ago however we return a few times a year. 21 Main St is a must. more on TripAdvisor

BEST RIBEYE EVER: WHAT A FANTASTIC RIB EYE DINNER I HAD THE BEST IS ALL I HAVE TO SAY AND SERVICE WAS GREAT ALL AROUND. more on Yahoo! Travel

Very attentive wait-staff. more on Yahoo! Travel

IT WAS FANTASTIC TO GO OUT TO DINNER WITH NO SCREAMING KIDS AND THE WAIT STAFF WAS THE BEST ACTUALLY TOLD YOU WHAT WAS GOOD AND NOT WORTH IT HAVENT SEEN A RESTAURANT THIS GOOD IN AGES more on Yahoo! Travel

Avg Rating

6 reviews

Top Reviews From TripAdvisor

First time we went, it was excellent. Second time, it was not so great - food was not up to par, ... more on TripAdvisor

Previously we had been to 21 Main two times, both on New Year's Eve and both times we were very happy with the service and food. Last night, we went with a party of 14 and it was not a good experience ... more on TripAdvisor

Stopped in for lunch in the week following Hurricane Irene. My family and I were impressed with the decor and the attention to service. The waitress and manager could not have been more pleasant. The ... more on TripAdvisor

We took friends out for a Birthday celebration. We all had steak and we were not disappointed. Service was excellent, kind, and friendly. I was surprised how local the restaurant was. The room was com ... more on TripAdvisor

Love this place more on TripAdvisor

Avg Rating

4 reviews

Top Reviews From Yahoo! Travel

The dinner for me and my wife was just over $100. The presentation is amazing but the flavors of the entrees are not. I had the special Ribeye which was way to fatty and chewy and lacked a marinaide taste. The portion was on the large ... more on Yahoo! Travel

My wife and I have been here even before it was 21 Main. The great experience starts with the beautiful building - fully lit up at night. Valet parking, a pleasant host and coat check. A nice bar to enjoy a cocktail while your table ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Thursday night is a steal at this great steak house....there are special "value" meals that would cost almost double on Fridays and Saturdays....the steaks are great, the veggies are crisp and fresh and the onion ... more on Yahoo! Travel

We always were very satisfied in the past...last Saturday night we were not....we had a table of six We were seated upstairs...temperature first cold then hot...noise from other tables was very annoying. Service...we ordered two bottles ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Top Reviews From Yahoo! Travel

Don't be fooled by 6 oysters on the half shell for $10. They employ that old restaurant trick of "halving" the raw ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Best ribeye ever: what a fantastic rib eye dinner I had the best is all I have to say and service was great all around. It was fantastic to go out to dinner with no screaming kids and the wait staff ... more on Yahoo! Travel

I've been at 21 Main every year for the past three years and it has got worse with every year. The food is good but I'm not blown away anymore like my wallet is. One thing I've noticed this year is that ... more on Yahoo! Travel