Tony's Italian Restaurant

4680 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43213

3.5

User Rating (4 sources) ×

Yahoo! Travel
TripAdvisor
CitySearch
Restaurantica

Phone:

614-224-8669,, +1 614 861 6117

Website:

www.tonysitalian.net

The Vibe :This is a classy, white-tablecloth kind of place housed in a historic brick building in the Brewery District. The decor hasn't changed in years but it doesn't have to.;For Starters :Choose from the classics, like Meat & ... more on CitySearch

Read Reviews

View Map & Directions

Ratings & Reviews for Tony's Italian Restaurant from Around the Web

Avg Rating

19 reviews

83% of guests recommend this place.

Atmosphere:

Dining:

Service & Staff:

Value:

Top Reviews from Around the Web:

The quality of the food was wonderful. more on Yahoo! Travel

The food is excellent, the lasagna I had was one of the best. more on CitySearch

When we go back to Columbus to visit family and friends, we always have to go to Tony's. more on TripAdvisor

I took my family there for a special dinner and it was awful! more on Yahoo! Travel

The atmosphere looks OK but when you arrive you don't even smell garlic!! more on Yahoo! Travel

Avg Rating

10 reviews

Top Reviews From TripAdvisor

I ate at Tony's for the first (and last) time a while back with a group of friends (all of whom raved about the place). Unfortunately my experience left a sour taste in my mouth. Our waitress was EXTR ... more on TripAdvisor

the food was average- the sauce on the pasta was very bitter and had a metallic taste. The sauce on the veal parm was much better.. Some friends had the sausage appetizer and thought it to be very goo ... more on TripAdvisor

The rehearsal dinner was here. The food was wonderful. The service was really good for our large party and the cannolis are (almost) ... more on TripAdvisor

We went here based on a groupon purchase. We have driven by for years but never stopped in. This place was great. The food quality was very good, the portion size good, and the atmosphere is intimate, ... more on TripAdvisor

**Very disappointed!!!** we had a large group of people (over 50), made the reservation over a month ago. Once we arrived the wait was very long before we were seated even though we arrived on time. T ... more on TripAdvisor

Avg Rating

5 reviews

Top Reviews From Yahoo! Travel

Good stuff more on Yahoo! Travel

By far the worst italian food in my life. more on Yahoo! Travel

I thought it was me but others i had dinner complained as well. I would not recommend. more on Yahoo! Travel

The atmosphere was very nice. We felt very relaxed, well serviced by the staff. The quality of the food was wonderful. ... more on Yahoo! Travel

We visited on Saturday evening, July 9, 2005. The atmosphere was quiet and relaxed, not overcrowded. We were a party of 7, our waitress was friendly and efficient. She did not write down our orders and they all arrived exactly ... more on Yahoo! Travel