»

Old Mill Inn Restaurant

500 West Main, Newcastle, Wyoming

3.0

User Rating (1 sources) ×

TripAdvisor

Phone:

+1 307 746 2711

Website:

theoldmillrestaurantsite.com

Read Reviews

View Map & Directions

Ratings & Reviews for Old Mill Inn Restaurant from Around the Web

Avg Rating

3.0

6 reviews

Atmosphere:

Dining:

Service & Staff:

Value:

Top Reviews from Around the Web:

This is a classic American roadfood restaurant, with food, decor, service, and ambience that is straight out of the mid-20th Century. more on TripAdvisor

The food just average was reasonably priced and the wait time average. more on TripAdvisor

I came into the restaurant 5 minutes before closing and, since I own a restaurant in Colorado, when asked what I would like to eat, I said, whatever they had not closed down. more on TripAdvisor

The food is just as genuine and original, real home cookin, just like your Granny used to make, if you had an especially blessed childhood. more on TripAdvisor

Considering the expensive prices of their food-which is just o.k.-and the service'below average'-in regard to the prices, there are restaurants in Toronto where the food taste better and the service i ... more on TripAdvisor

Avg Rating

6 reviews

Top Reviews From TripAdvisor

If you should happen to find yourself in Newcastle, Wyoming (which is easy to do if you're taking the non-Interstate route from Mount Rushmore to Yellowstone), be sure to stop at the Old Mill Inn. Thi ... more on TripAdvisor

We stopped in for a bit and ate in the pub area. I had the soup and salad bar which was located in the very back - in a sperate part of the business - you had to pass through the ice cream shop and in ... more on TripAdvisor

I came into the restaurant 5 minutes before closing and, since I own a restaurant in Colorado, when asked what I would like to eat, I said, whatever they had not closed down. The chef insisted that he ... more on TripAdvisor

After waiting for over an hour for our food, it arrived in various forms of cold, over-cooked, and under-cooked. We only saw two servers in a crowded restaurant on a Friday evening. I would not recomm ... more on TripAdvisor

We ate dinner here after stopping at the Sundowner Inn for the night. They recommended it and it was across the street and had good food. The young waitress who waited on us was very good and efficien ... more on TripAdvisor